The great debate

i cant speak for xenoblade 2 because i didnt play it but the other three are good; rebirth is outstanding and my favorite by far

Lost odyssey

It's good but blue dragon was better

Expedition is a much better game it's not even comparable

xenoblade

Never played BD, I'll take your word for it.

The image was 100% made by someone who hates Xenoblade 2 and just wants to use it for ragebait since it's an easy target. As if each of those games on their own don't receive their far share of being shit on.

Xenoblade 2 does not belong there. I've only played Rebirth and Metaphor. Waiting for Expedition 33 to get a restock for physical copies

Clair Obscur >>>>> Rebirth >>>>>> XB2 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> dogshit >>>>>>>> ur mom >>>>>>>>>> metaslop

Xenoblade 2 is the best one

Metaphor, FF7, but Original and XC2.
Simple as.

2 is not even the best Xeno game
Still Gears forever gears

Xenoblade 2 belongs there and it's better than the other 3.

Metaphor > Xenoblade 2 = Clair Obsur Expedition 33 > powergap > Rebirth.

xenoblade 2

I legitimately find it hard to even take this game serious

Xeno 2 > Expedition 33 > Rebirth > Metaphor

All 4 games are good, tho.
Happy to provide pics if you think I haven't played them.

I haven't played FF:R or Metaphor, but E33 is massively overrated. I'm general I'd go Persona/Metaphor > Xeno > FF > E33

XB2Fags really be like "The great debate"

E33 > Metaphor > XC2 > Rebirth

So I guess there's no point in making threads like this if your only "argument" is metacritic score.

Exactly

you haven't played them

So why did you make this thread then?

inb4 it wasn't me

E33 = Metaphor > Rebirth >>> XBC2

Now you're getting it.

Yeah. I just like the boxes.

it wasn't me

Relink

Metaphor > XC2 >> Rebirth >> E33

this but replace e33 with xenoblade

BD is not even close to being as good as LO. LO was what FF13 should have been. BD has been forgotten with time.

Metaphor

Dropped after about 15 hours. Ugly, dogshit writing, bland everything.

Rebirth

Watched my GF play some of it, possibly the gayest game on this list. Shit's all over the original and adds tedious open world bloat.

XBC2

Not played yet, currently 80 or so hours into X, which is fantastic.

E33

Playing at the moment also, pretty good so far despite some visual effects giving off that grossly distinct UE5 look.
Pic related mogs the lot.

No one pretends to like SMTV now that's no longer a switch exclusive.

LO is good but it just doesn't have that same vibe that made BD special for me, it's probably nostalgia talking but I found everything except the story to be better, the music, gameplay, style, it's all better in blue dragon, especially that boss fight theme, some of my favourite Nobuo tracks are in it

How come its always rebirth and not og FF7

why are the same exact threads about this game being spammed every couple of hours?

Metaphor is the only good game there.
All xenoblades are good except 2.

Is t-that... anime booba?! AIIIIEEEEEEEE

Rebirth>E33>>>>>>>Metaphor

Xenoblade shouldn’t even be there.

E33 just killed smt for me with how fucking mid V was. We better get more sandfall games

So MetaGODS won? BASED!

Nah.

Your AAA PS3 game should not be there.

But Metacritic has spoken. Your frog slop is worse than Metaphor by authority of the people

metaphor is ugly but still looks better than ue5 slop

Rebirth > Exp33 >>> Metaphor

The only thing it comes up with Rebirth is the towers which could have been removed, and just reduce chadley to VR stuff. But the rest (story, characters, gameplay, music, etc) is pretty damn good.
Exp33 is a good game, i just didnt like the actual gameplay. I think it is balanced terribly and it affects the sidecontent tackle and even the final dungeon/boss. That alone makes me game a little worse than rebirth. There are some things that i dont like, but i dont think it is bad. Its just not for me.
Havent played xenoblade 2 but i feel like it should be xenoblade 3? its the most recent one and people usually say xeno2 is the black sheep of the franchise.
Metaphor is just mediocre all around. There are some things i like, take any topic around this game and theres mediocrity. Gameplay? check. Characters? check. Story/storytelling? double check. Graphics? Check. Presentation? check. Music? pretty good, but it got repetitive after a while. It needed some uniqueness to it, like character themes or something. Check. Side content? check. Finished it on ps5. It had some good ideas and i would have definitely done things differently, but just as it is, it is mediocre.

achievementfag

opinion discarded

Metaphor >>>>>>>>> E33 >>> XC2 >>>>>>>>> Rebirth

Why does Xenoblade 2 cause so much seething on this web zone?

Xenoblade Chronicles 3 was better than 2.

No it wasn't.

Yes it was. Every other Xenoblade game is better than 2.

this turd is more polished than this other turd

both of you are fucking retarded

Xenoblade 2 should be going up against Honkai Star Rail and not the big boys

Clair Obscur > shit straight from my asshole > the other three

Cope.

I’m not normally a contrarianfag like a lot of this board but Metaphor Redditazio might genuinely be the most shilled game I’ve ever seen in contrast to its actually quality.

Like it’s not even bad it’s just a 6-7/10 generic jrpg. I even tried to force myself to like it more multiple times but all I got was a persona reskin with a YA fire emblem tier story that never fucking ends.

Seriously what do nips have against story editors in every artistic medium?

MMO style combat.

lel

Ok, I'll trust only in your opinion ITT.

Why is FFX and Lost Odyssey constantly brought up by 33Cucks, weirdly fucking specific

why are games that this game clearly ripped from being brought up in threads about it

ripped FFX

How? Looks more like french Persona 5 than anything FFX related.

XC2

Nice try, OP

FFXII

I’m not normally a contrarianfag like a lot of this board but Metaphor Redditazio might genuinely be the most shilled game I’ve ever seen in contrast to its actually quality.

nigga on this board metaphor was just an excuse for endless culture war threads with the same 5 screenshots. the shilling came from outside with shit like 94 metacritic average

Those are the two most recent rpgs it clearly resembles. You could go back further and claim LoD or FF8 but LO/X get the job done. It has their spirit. More akin to those games than the high school friend simulator Persona stuff.

Good

Slop

Slop

Good

See what I mean? FFXII will never be unaninously embraced as a classic. I loved it, though.

Shit game with good character designs.

yeah i found it ass already back then, so i guess it's a matter of tastes

Enel thread

Xenoblade 2 is kino

Good game with shitty character designs

Rebirth. I couldn't care much about the rest.

Xinoblade

Tendies and FFcultists are truly insufferable.

everyone already forgot Metaphor

left absolutely no legacy, no fanbase, no mark left on the genre

but (((they))) keep trying to force it as "one of the greats" and "the most intelligent RPG"

still using the worst xenoblade game to represent the series

Rebirth easily. I didn't play xenoblade but i'm sure it's trash

>everyone already forgot Metaphor

>left absolutely no legacy, no fanbase, no mark left on the genre

>but (((they))) keep trying to force it as "one of the greats" and "the most intelligent RPG"

You just know who is behind this.

this but backwards

It's just Enel and his discord again.
They do this shit putting XC2 next to modern games to pretend it's still relevant. They'll be doing this even after the next 3 Xenoblade games are released, unless they do a 2 DE first, then that game will take over the slots instead.

FFVII rebirth comes out

it stays the most discussed game

metaphor comes out

discussion lasts a week and it drops in rating hard

clair obscure and oblivion come out, stay in top place for a while

oblivion already defeated

tick tock exp33 bros

>FFVII rebirth comes out

>it stays the most discussed game

>metaphor comes out

>discussion lasts a week and it drops in rating hard

>clair obscure and oblivion come out, stay in top place for a while

>oblivion already defeated

tick tock exp33 bros

KEKEKE STAY MAD FAGGOT LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Holy shit you are truly ass mad about Rebirth.

That's Xenoblade 3

I'm looking forward to the next Xeno game for the Switch 2. Really hope they push it to the limit like they did with X on the Wii U.

He posted it

The anti-3 sisters are afraid.

best story: E33

best narrative: E33

best characters: Rebirth

best combat: Rebirth

best dungeons: Rebirth

best OST: Rebirth/E33, can't decide

best world: E33

best menus (kek): Metaphor

best level design: XC2

best villain: Metaphor

best rpg elements: Metaphor

best boss fights: Rebirth

best side content: Rebirth

Not as afraid as the anti-2 sisters.

No sane person believes a xeno 2 fan made this image.
Most people use xeno 2 as bait because hating anime and japan is the current popular thing on modern Anon Babble(4cuck), and xeno 2 is the most unashamed jrpg out there, which is why it's so loved by fans and hated by tourists. Don't be fooled into thinking the people posting these baits like any other xeno games either, they hate all of them, and for some it goes deeper than that(like being against Japan or Nintendo for example), they regularly switch between shitposting xeno 2 and 3 to derail xeno threads, one of them (I don't doubt it's just one dude and no one else) tried shitposting in the 8moe thread, but since he couldn't samefag there, people just ignored him and he gave up after he couple of posts.

No u!!!

3 antis can't meme

Samefag

Hello Enel

metaphor

Disappointed, very good but disappointed me

FF

Didn't play

XBC2

Pretty good, horrible pacing sometimes, great end

Exped

Loving it so far
Here's the GOAT

It's this guy btw, I saw him posting the same stale baits in the other site just to get ignored.

Meds.

So as you see, the thread was made by the one schizo who keeps shitting up xenoblade threads with his schizophrenia and probably other threads too that I'm not aware of... Now that we all know this, surely these threads won't get any more replies, right?

It's this guy btw, I saw him posting the same stale baits on twitter and his discord.

This same thread was made just the other day, and probably the one before that too. the discord has been doing variations for years now if you want to get technical.

This is the best bait image I have seen in awhile. It has like 5 layers of jokes

Very much doubt it's a discord, It really seems like it's mostly one dude, with maybe a couple more that shitpost in response to him in xeno threads, I have heard people saying that he also spams in other threads, but I wouldn't know about that.

Xcucks are mentally ill

If you like remake you are literally retarded and your opinion is completely worthless.

I don't think Rebirth will remain in the "GOAT JRPG" discussion for years to come. Expedition 33 will.

Babby's first RPG where everything outside of combat is a hallway and "missions" are just walking back and forth.

Nah, somewhere between TTYD's battle system and Origami King's map design there is a good RPG.

Xenoblade 2 was only unpopular with certain people because of the overt hentai aesthetic, you can't honestly believe Marxthaphor is an actually better game.

It was, 3 is just a better game overall, you may not like the story as much but 3 doesn't have all the stupid niggles 2 has like field skills or the obtuse-ass menus.

3 is just a better game overall

How so?