To this day an unsurpassed RPG experience

Playing the game made me wonder how regular people live in that monster infested world

I loved this game but stopped playing 2 like 3 hours in. Don't know why, but the game just didn't have the same feeling.

Witcher 1

Janky soulful Europg

Witcher 2

muh sqls racism is BAD okay

Witcher 3

Porno for women

no shit

LOTR visuals compared to grim slav lands

everything is vivid lush greens

super linear corridor forests

TRAP IT WITH YRDEN

depending on who you side the game plays very different so 50/50 chance its really shit

dogshit gameplay
great everything else

I bet the remake will be
great gameplay
shit everything else
and there will be people defending it saying the original was unplayable and the people that prefer it are posers or nostalgic

2 is the worst witcher game
1 was mostly a personal rpg story with geralt and his amnesia
2 just ignores that and there's a big story with kings dying and war shit and no progress at all is made on geralt returning his memories to the point 3 starts with they saying that between the two games geralt just got his memories back

The chapter 2 is the "that part"

I tried to finish it three times now but still can't. It's just an awful game of backtracking.

RPGs are garbage. Witcher 1 is great specifically because it's not a RPG. No turn-based crap, no lame character creation or party bloat. It's an adventure game. Just call it what it is.

The second game is pretty ugly, and the combat is terrible

I love RPGs that feel more like an adventure than a RPG
Without a party or character creation

He literally starts recovering more of his memory as you progress through the game.

Ruined by leftists

the series always had awful gameplay

Unironicly liked this more that Witcher 2. Havent played Witcher 3

weird given its my favourite

2 is grimdark GoT knockoff, it lacks soul of 1 and 3

I found this in a bargain bin when the enhanced edition released in like 2006. It’s pure eurojank but a lot of fun, I had way too much fun collecting all the cards it even had nudity without any mods lol if you played this as a young teenager when it came out you’d have fun. I tried getting into Gothic before Witcher but I didn’t like it much but Witcher 1 was far better at the time. Some shit was stupid like the recycled NPCs. But I still remember the game fondly, the knight was a bro and the doctor was hot. The game was really lengthy too and had an interesting story. I’ll always say it I am shocked but also happy at how big the series became.

You can really tell roughly when Witcher 2 was made based just on menu design and bloom.
I remember the ending felt really sudden, just as the game got going for me.
1 is """special""" but good, 3 is more easily digested.

You just know the remake is going to suck all the genuine grounded soul out of it and make it feel like a generic UE5 environment like every other fucking game

Haven't played the first Witcher game, but 2 and 3's combat were extremely boring.

Which games had combat you like

Paper Mario

Then you'd love Witcher 1's combat

SINCE THE BEGINNING OF TIME

one of the last western rpg's to still have SOVL

this game is literally just walking 90% of the time
and people call W3 a walking sim

you also play most of the time as Geralt.
+ the fact you mostly kill monsters.
And there are NO redbull in the whole game.

I saw this game get hyped as the GOAT for years and when I finally decided to check it out I just got bored and dropped it after 60 hours of typical open world slog.

I dont even think the original is 60 hours long so you might want to polish your shitposting game for the next thread