This was on sale the other day and bought it on a whim...

This was on sale the other day and bought it on a whim. Trying to decide if I want to return it or actually open it and play.
I've played 2 other Ys games so far but beaten neither, Memories of Celceta and 8. I have tons of fun with each of the games. Love exploring, finding new shit, the combat, visiting new towns, etc. But the games overstay their welcome for me after about 40 or so hours. I expect this to be the same but I couldn't pass up on the $30 price. What does this game do better than MoC and 8, and what does it do worse? I haven't played 9.

should've waited for the upcoming definitive edition

This

when's it release

What does it change or add? I mean then I'd also need to wait for it to drop down to $30 too.

I've played 2 other Ys games so far but beaten neither, Memories of Celceta and 8.

But the games overstay their welcome for me after about 40 or so hours.

Play Ys Oath in Felghana and Ys Origin. Ys I & II Chronicles is also good, but know that the gameplay is very much of a bygone era.

OP said Ys games overstay their welcome, why would he want more filler content/bloat? Unless Proud Nordics adds an ending where Adol fucks Karja and gets her pregnant, there's no reason to touch it.

Combat is fluid but the challenge design isn't really there.
Bosses can be ok.
Less bangers in the OST but still good.
Character progression is cool with the nodes.
Nicely animated and runs like butter.
Too many side characters you don't care about unlike 8.
Ship traversal goes from annoying to just not annoying, never great.
Story and main cast is nice.
It's pretty fun at its core, it just needed more enemy encounter scenarios and difficult dungeons that drain your resources.
Just wait for proud edition or whatever it's called.

Will any game ever top AC Black Flag for ships?
No, none will.

If you were able to tolerate two Ys games already then it is impossible for you to be disappointed in another

Supposedly they are fixing the story and rebalancing the game or something, it isn't just some expansion content.

They teased new characters and a new landmass.

He didn't finish either, and I don't blame him. Ys has never been deep enough to be some 50 hour JRPG. The earlier, shorter ones milk the formula for exactly what it's worth and nothing more.

gameplay peaks at ys 8

gets shittier and shittier every other installment

why do they do this
just make ys 8.2

8 had more time in the oven than a typical Ys title.

Play Ys Oath in Felghana and Ys Origin

Why these two in particular?

If you hate Ys games overstaying their welcome then why the fuck would you buy a modern Ys game which all do that lmao

5-10 hours short.
Anything pre 7 is really.

Because they're short and sweet action RPGs that emphasize the fast combat over most everything else. It lacks the bells and whistles of modern Ys games but in return, they do one thing and do it very well.

They're from when the series had minimal story and were just short and sweet action games that focused on boss fights. Ys Seven is when the games started getting longer.

Because I do tend to like them for a solid amount of time and love exploring, heading to new towns, getting new equipment, etc.

Interesting/ I think I'll check them out. I'm sorta leaning towards returning Ys and keeping my promise to not buy any new games until I've beaten Stellar Blade.

should've waited for the upcoming definitive edition

Te fuckers announced the week I found a very cheap second hand copy of X. Reminds me of when Sony announced they were giving away the Uncharted Trilogy the day after I finished beating the PS3 versions of those games.

the games got longer and longer but they never really got better or really evolved to make that length feel like it was worth it, the stories are still just absolutely generic jrpg shit but now the cutscenes take 10x as long
hell id argue they got worse if anything

9's gameplay is objectively better than 8's, even if 8 is a better sum of its parts

rebalancing, more endings and more content in after game.

No its not, 9 feels slow as fuck.

well, it's not

It is though. The movement overall was purposely slowed down compared to 8. You can barely dash jump anymore.

bro, your gale boots?

still slower

fast enough. you can also run up walls and glide and use a grappling hook + the charge attack makes the fights more dynamic by adding a source of mana which you can charge up while performing other actions. you also have a buff to go along with your ultimate. all of this makes the gameplay an objective upgrade, and i'm probably forgetting stuff

I'll only buy it if it doesn't have a meme dogshit localization.

Xseed hasn't said shit and the game hasn't released in Japan yet.

Really it can be 1, 2, Felghana, and Origin. Just avoid Ark of Napishtin, it fucking sucks. 1 kind of sucks in the first half too, but Darm Tower more than makes up for it.

In all honesty she probably did have the most developed relationship with Adol out of all of his girls. I actually ended up liking her a lot because of it. They did actually feel like a newlywed betrothed couple.

Ys 8 was genuinely one of the most compelling games I've played, something about it just sucked me in and made me want to 100% it.

I've seldom Gosling'd at a game harder than I did in chapters 6 and 9

113324513_p2.png - 800x800, 329.45K

I just create my own personal headcanon at the end of every Ys game.

huhu
how do we stop nuys games from just devolving into flash guard > mash your highest dps skill > repeat until boss dies gameplay

What was her fucking problem?

Psycho that wanted Adol’s dick.

karja says she and adol were getting real hot and heavy

rosa is the only one who even reacts

kek

She freaks out again immediately in the crow’s nest and her and Ezer lose their shit together when Karja talks about how her mom’s ghost wanted Adol as a son-in-law

Momina had such a shit life

IMG_5018.jpg - 250x250, 13.16K

imagine the smell

husband's character development is he fucking dies

it's not even part of the main story

Genuinely what were they thinking with this

YS 8 has a remake exclusive to China.

What was wrong with the story?

They didn't mention changing anything about the existing story. All the new stuff seems to be additions to the side with a new area and new characters.

husband become a drunken abuser after becoming a cripple that loses his job

younger son dies tragically

older son becomes estranged and leaves

husband becomes a drunkard that loses his mind and memory and wanders off

finally get them back in her life as her home and livelihood are destroyed

son tries to kill her husband

husband dies in the most pointless and anticlimactic death ever

son leaves home again afterwards

Yeah, that was not the best resolution they could have gone with.

He wasn't going to get better in his decayed mental state so she can at least move on now.

I enjoyed the game more than IX, I just wish it had some environmental variety instead of 90% of the islands being standard beaches/grasslands. I played it not even half a year ago and a lot of it already blends together in my mind.

She has a full grown child and she has to deal with internalizing two nuclear family deaths. Face it anon, she’s never going to have a happy life now and will probably spend the rest of it alone

she’s never going to have a happy life now

She already wasn't going to having to take care of a mentally ill drunkard.

I’m just saying she could have gotten a happier ending than she did considering how oddly tragic her backstory was for such a friendly side character

beach, swamp, grasslands, mountains, ancient civilizations, magical alternate dimensions, pirate ship, secret ancient government underground hiding isoteric knowledge, fuck else you need cracka?