Looking back, was it slop or kino?

Question

Looking back, was it slop or kino?

Well it certainly was a movie.

It fantastic. But the fact I always park my horse on top of whatever animal I skin so I get the fast skinning animation isn't a good thing and kind of represents my feelings on the entire game.

i thought it was one of the worst games
it is barely interactive

he doesn't appreciate the absurd attention to detail in animations

zoomie needs instant gratification

grand horse auto

kinoslop

It turned me into a horse girl. I don't want to take HRT but I hear being obsessed with horses is a female thing.

it's a decent movie that stretches on way too long and repeats plot beats too much for its own good

exploration is comfy, missions are far too one-note and linear. Shooting is middling at best.

he’s gay…

he’s gay for you, Dutch

anyone else think this scene came completely out of nowhere? rest of the game was cool though

play game

grind to get best satchel

glitch to Guarma for the lulz

finish chapter 2

chapter 3 goes woke with Sadie

stop playing forever

Great open world and details
Overrated as hell story

tech demo

Sadie is based and you are gay, saar

Nigger there's no way you're still amused by the 500th skinning animation. Same thing with nu-Doom's glory kills, and I'm shocked there's even 1 person who misses them. It's repetitive and rapes pacing. If you actually spend a significant amount of time playing the game in question, I don't know how it does anything but get on your nerves.

it's worse in first-person view
having the controls taken away from you in service of some stupid animation in first-person just feels so much worse than in third-person
it should never happen and both games are garbage for this

Kino open world.
Slop story.

It's already archived in history as one of the greatest games ever made. Miyazaki made Elden Ring open world with a horse mount because of this game.

but it looks le cool

but the detail

I don't think people who like these or make these really play the game that much. The cosmetic abstraction eventually fades from all games when you play them enough and all you're left with mechanically is time wasting crap. No one in history has ever played Quake and said it'd be nice if combat just paused every 5 seconds.

Kino, would be perfection if it had a better inventory system and they combined the online blank slate experience in the single player world

yeah
i think it is probably the worst thing going on lately
dont take the control away from the player and the game is better for it
this is cutscenes, quicktimes shits, animations, everything
it ruins the game

I don’t understand how money works, cus throughout the game Arthur will give money to couples that need a fresh start somewhere new and all he needs is to give them like $50 meanwhile Dutch is always like “We need more money!” even though the gang has like 20 thousand saved up and Arthur by himself is walking around with like 5k by chapter 3

fun for one playthrough, zero replay appeal

I have a good 1k hours in the game across platforms and it unironically did not bother me. Loved all the amazing animations. Sometimes I’d jump onto my horse from a weird angle on a slope and see the unique animation and just be like fuckin he’ll that’s beautiful. It shouldn’t be the design philosophy of most games, maybe not any game, except rockstar kino. Their games have felt like driving a boat for a while but I like it. My character feels like a real little dude inside a physical universe. Skinning animals is a weird thing to tackle. The rdr1 cutaway is probably better game design but yeah I don’t care I want them to go all out in whatever ways they want. I just accept I’m playing a slow burn with red dead

Slop. I never was able to finish it, it's such an uninteresting drag.

Noone is denying that part of it is a cinematic simulator experience. Quake is not that so you can't make that comparison

Quake was brought up as a comparison to GKs in nu-Doom. No one ever asked for that until id all but forced players to do it.

cinematic

The reason is irrelevant. The point is that control is being taken away.

m- maybe if i cal him a zoomie then they’ll a-agree with me!!!!!!

Kek, denied

Shorter attention span: you won't enjoy it
Longer attention span: you will enjoy it

I'm pissed that they added fast travel from makeshift camps

Dutch is retarded and retroactively doesn't deserve any of the respect he got in the first game.

What if people don't mind control being taken away? A game like RDR2 is closer to a movie than other games and people obviously like it

One of the greatest representations of this medium being genuine art. The game is like a moving painting. So realistic yet also stylized in just so many ways. Everytime I come back to it I'm still blown away with what they accomplished, there's such a tangiblity to the world. The lighting, the sense of scale, the plethora of different biomes, all of the unique NPCs, the sheer amount of animals and all of their own unique behaviors and animations. From a technical standpoint it's objectively a masterpiece and just one giant flex on this industry. I really doubt any other developer in this industry could replicate what they accomplished here.

That's called ludonarrative dissonance and I wouldn't spend too much time dwelling on it. Gameplay and story can't always be 1:1 with one another, especially in an open world game.

Jewish. The scum think they can get away with that if they pile on unconnected pretty things. It just makes all of it invalid.

Im on Chapter 2 with $7k from all the gold bars you can find. If you preorder the digital version there is a $3k treasure hunt that came with it. So i would be at $10k if i preordered. The only problem is there isn't much to buy in the game.

From a technical standpoint it's objectively a masterpiece and just one giant flex on this industry.

I honestly expect nothing less from them at this point.

Good game

Popular

Of course it's slop. Only bad games no one has ever heard of can be kino.

boring crap. you endure the slog only to witness your character dying begging like a cuck.

Both. Its 10/10 for me because i LOVE westerns, but i can totally see how its like 6/10 for someone who doesnt give a shit about them.

You can do that in 1 though.

I love westerns, but this one ain't it. It's just gay Netflix melodrama for redditor pseuds.

game has realistic horse mechanics bro!!1

you are not a game developer and never will be fucking faggot. we are consumers and the game is fucking boring, that's a categorical failure and it's the crux.

Forgot to specify that i stay in chapter 4, fucking around.

You're out of your gachaslop playing mind. It's one of if not the best recreation of that era ever made.

we are consumers and the game is fucking boring