What are the first games you think of?

Final Fantasy X-2

DOS2
Demon's Souls
New Vegas
Binding of Isaac Rebirth
Red Alert 2 / Yuri's Revenge
Sin & Punishment
The Evil Within
RE4
Metal Slug
Red Dead Redemption
Fallout 3
Pikmin 2
Rollercoaster Tycoon (Deluxe or OpenRCT2)
Sly 2
Portal 2
Batman Arkham Asylum
Wipeout Omega Collection
Ratchet & Clank 1&2
Mass Effect 1
LBP1
Animal Crossing
Cookie Clicker
XCOM EU
Halo 3
MGS3
Dark Souls III
Catherine
Star Fox 64
Dead Cells
Cuphead
Hotline Miami 2
Darkest Dungeon

For the time:
Tekken 3

Dark Souls II
Expedition 33

Katamari Damacy

Fuck no

Awful camera that you can't control despite tons of free buttons

dash move requires you to wiggle both sticks like a spastic and half the time doesn't register, the other half the time you go in a totally different direction because it's impossible to stay pointed where you want while wiggling the sticks

Very inconsistent physics. A moving hazard barely bigger than your Katamari can hit you at 3mph and send you absolutely flying while other times you get nailed by a large, fast moving hazard and barely move

Hitting into a small step at low speed causes you to crash and lose objects, but you can get suctioned up a step taller than your ball without even trying. The pbysics of traversing ledges/walls/hills is extremely wonky and inconsistent

Objects' physical size don't match up with their size required to roll, oftentimes you will not be able to roll an object that your ball is way bigger than, but also vice versa where you can roll up comparatively massive items as a small ball

You can easily get caught on terrain and bug the fuck out, while at other times your objects just clip right through

NPCs constantly repeat the same lines of dialogue over and over, even interrupting gameplay to do so

The globe has specific regions for stages (even explicitly mentioned by The King) but none of these locations are represented at all; they're all just generic Japanese locations with Japanese items scattered about.

Levels feel very samey and repetitive. Different levels of the same environment type have the exact same copy-pasted level structure, and even most of the same items, with only very few objects being unique per level

overly loud and annoying 30 second countdown plays every stage

No way to restart level without completely exiting to home planet

It's a cool and novel concept but the camera, controls, physics, and object sizing are just so fucking awful that it drags the whole experience way down
It's like a 6-7/10. WLK improved everything

This is every game I've given a 10

most safe reddit-tier poser faggot opinion I've ever seen

Also

both fucking Horizon games

fucking EA Onions Wars

disgusting

clair obscure expedition 33

fucking finally someone else that shares my opinion on Katamari
it's one of Anon Babble's sacred cows, I complained about it throughout the years and said it's basically just an average indie game by today's standards and practically got crucified for it

video games

good

Deus Ex
Super Metroid
DKC2
Silent Hill
Diablo
theres 5

Hotline Miami 2

Silent Hill

Diablo

Fucking how...? Diablo especially is so mediocre.

good job reading almost the entire list retard

that's the joke

Your favorite games :)

Into the Breach
Celeste
Donkey Kong: Tropical Freeze

None because all games have at least one little thing i don't like. A 10/10 would be a game with literally zero improvable things

After 30+ years of vidya I have to say there's been no legit 10/10. A 10/10 would be a forever game and the only thing close to that is modded TES games which doesn't count because the base games are mostly garbage.

Sonic

LMAO

Why do people like Tropical Freeze so much?

I 200%ed the game, and I thought it would eventually click, but it never really did. I still like the level themes and OST, but in terms of actual level design and flow, only the temple worlds and secret worlds really succeeded at that. Too much focus on the level theming sabotaged the actual platforming design. Also the game has literally over 100ms of input lag which feels fucking terrible in a 2D precision platformer.

Skyrim
Nuff' said.

Astlibra

Ocarina of Time
Majora's Mask
Resident Evil 4
Resident Evil 2
Metal Gear Solid 1
Castlevania SOTN
Final Fantasy 7
Deus Ex
Super Metroid
Dark Souls 1

10/10 means 100% perfect without any flaws or subjective issues

1/1 means 100% perfect without any flaws or subjective issues

brainlet posters

I'm sure it looks that way to you, way up there on your midwit peak.

Final Fantasy 7

It's so fucking overrated.

I beat it for the first time last year on OG hardware (30 year old zoomer), and while it wasn't bad, it was very underwhelming; so dry and boring that it took me almost two months to finish even when I didn't do much side content. Just a drag.

everything is just so damn slow-paced from animations to transitions to loading to constant cutscenes and monologues

combat is braindead autopilot button mashing. Regular enemies are just braindead cannon fodder for grinding that pose zero risk whatsoever. Even bosses are a complete joke, and you will only ever fail to poorly telegraphed gotcha trollshit

camera angles in combat are obnoxious and constantly obscure the fight

targeting enemies and allies in fights is very finicky. Having to actually point at 3D models instead of the list of names is baffling

magic spells are samey and don't really fill a niche or usecase, with few meaningful tradeoffs

no descriptions for any spells or items while in combat

no symbols for status elements and no way to view them

translation is extremely shoddy, full of grammar/spelling errors and nonsensical engrish

dialogue boxes look amateurish, appearing all over and blocking parts of the screen and character names only appearing their first line; when new, unnamed characters speak, no name is shown, and the dialogue box appears the same as if the previous character is speaking

d-pad digital movement feels awful to navigate isometric maps; you will frequently bang into walls and go back the way you came on screen transition

prerendered backgrounds are unclear and unintuitive regarding what areas you can traverse or interact with

constantly have to go into towns and talk to every Tom, Dick, and Harry to advance the plot

99% of the objects in the world can't be interacted with, while a few arbitrarily can and give zero indication

It depends on what you expect out of any game, but I think that Stardew Valley, Bomb Rush Cyberfunk, and Cruelty Squad are 3 examples of games where it feels like the creator(s) achieved exactly what they set out to achieve. Like, well realized visions are what I'd call 10/10 games.

Jesus wept. You're a fucking zoomer alright.

dank souls 1

I've enjoyed many hundreds of games from 5th gen and earlier. FF7 is just overrated junk.

This is not a good list anon

Fallout 3

Stopped reading there

It's [Morrowind/Oblivion/Skyrim] but better in every possible way from atmosphere to quests to factions to combat to exploration. The hate is very much unwarranted.

kingdom hearts 358/2 days

not because of quality but because of number divided by number

Pizza Tower

Joust

Portal

Rocket League

Ghost Trick

DKC Tropical Freeze

Inside

Ico

Hollow Knight

Yoshi's Island

Plants vs Zombies

a lot of those are quite simple, but I find simpler games are usually closer to being perfect since very little stands in the way of their design goals

personal 10/10s with more obvious flaws, although ones that don't stop it being a 10 to me:

Shadow of the Colossus

Resident Evil 4

Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee

TimeSplitters 2

Metroid Prime

3 games with dogshit gameplay

?

holy fucking reddit.

kys

Tropical Freeze was so good.
I beat it twice on Wii U and thought it was amazing during its launch year. The OST was phenomenal too. I recently played it again after many years on Steam deck via CEMU and its better than I remember.
youtube.com/watch?v=JDiPCSXJZy0

NTA but what are you smoking?

atmosphere

featureless Capital wasteland full of identical empty concrete rectangles & subway tunnels

quests

main quest is the dumbest in the entire series, somebody post the old screencap from THIS VERY BOARD about how stupid the fight over the water and use of the GECK was. Side quests and companions were also forgettable, including the DLC

factions

faction writing was terrible in 3 also, especially for the brotherhood of steel

combat

clunky buggy shit and VATs isn't fun

exploration

featureless gray concrete etc. etc.

Luigi's Mansion

sorry I didn't list a load of tryhard poser bullshit like Cosmology of Kyoto, Ikaruga, Umihara Kawase and Chulip

No, instead you tried to pick artsy games instead of what you actually enjoy. You're a poser faggot and should kys.

Funny how you will never apply these same standards to any TES game, they would fail the shit test way worse.

Bloodborne/Demon's
Vampire Savior
GG AC+R
DMC3SE
Doom
Lord of Destruction
Darkwood
Silent Hill
Super Turbo
Gran Turismo 2
Hotline Miami
Megaman X
Contra 3

There are TES games mentioned in the post I replied to, not mine
I didn't say anything about TES at all

Take your meds

Cosmology of Kyoto
Ikaruga
Umihara Kawase
Chulip

Freespace 2

I enjoy every single one of those games you faggot

Baldur's Gate 3
Red Dead 2
Deus Ex
Clair Obscur
Hades
Returnal

Man leave some bait for the rest of us

don't actually pick games that are unique, or interesting, or well-designed, or fun, or memorable, or actually took risks

no, instead just pick safe, lame games just because they don't have obvious flaws and didn't take risks (except Hollow Knight, that game is one of the worst pieces of shit in gaming and no way subjectively or objectively should EVER be considered 10/10)

gay list, kys

Joust

may as well put Pong on there

Portal

completely obsoleted by the sequel in every possible way

Ghost Trick

Story is decent, puzzles are boring and a bit contrived. It's just a solid game, but not even close to a 10/10 or a favorite game of all time.

Tropical Freeze

zero flow to any of the levels, huge amounts of input lag, poor visual communication with hazards, way too much focus on level theming over actual gameplay and level design. It's a decent, but highly overrated platformer. The OST is great, the bossfights are done well for a platformer, some level themes are interesting (at the cost of actual competent level design), but that's it.

Inside

There's no way you genuinely think this.

Ico

The combat alone is enough to drag the entire game down. It's so fucking awful and just comes up constantly. Ico is one of those games you can more appreciate the vision rather than actually being fun to play.

Hollow Knight

one of the worst games of all time, not even characters here for me to air my grievances with this piece of shit

Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee

fucking dogshit eurojank cinematic platformer with some of the most awful movement of all time, dull fucking level designs, just a total fucking drag to play. Literally the only redeeming quality is the art design.

It's so blatantly obvious you are lying and just trying to bullshit for clout. Just be genuine.

backloggd troon

believes 10/10 and his favorites aren't synonymous

die you tranny freak

showing your age with that description of Abe's Oddysee

clout

it's an anonymous image board fellow anonymous poster

Fallout 3

Based chad

I'm in my 30s. It's shit. kys.

Clair Obscur Expedition 33

Ocarina of Time

Chrono Cross.

Did you play and enjoy Blackthorne for the SNES? It's one of my favorite games

I'm also NTA

Hi-fi Rush

only safe, unambitious games with extremely narrow scopes that take zero risks and have zero friction can be 10/10

I fucking hate this midwit mentality.

Chud Adventure IV

We Love Katamari
Super Metroid
Final Fantasy 6
New Super Mario Bros Wii
Bloodborne
Grand Theft Auto San Andreas

CA2 (Chud Adventure II) was clearly the peak of the series tho

DAYTONA USA
Neo Turf Masters
Virtua Cop 2

Forever games without flaw. Absolutely perfect in what they set out to do. If you can't shift drift, don't know what a justice shot is or never got a hole in one or consistent eagles on par 5s, your opinion is going in the same garbage can as fromtards, moba players, mmoidiots, and jarpiggies.

Hello from Anon Babble lol

Ratings are dumb

It's from 2011 which makes it older than some of the posters in this thread

I'm sure your taste is perfect and whatever games you think are 10/10 are objectively correct, you raging baboon

Ocarina of time. Still the GOAT.

boomers

They're all unplayable garbage until Chud Adventure XIX

muh objectively correct

point
your head

kys

1. Sonic Adventure 2

2. Space Station 13

3. Fallout New Vegas

4. Team Fortress 2

5. Cave Story

6. Shining Force

7. Yakuza 0

8. Majora's Mask

9. Bomberman Hero

10. Halo 3

There, about the only 10 games I'd have, at some point, would've given a perfect 5/5. Online games are harder to judge since their glory days have passed. But I am rating them at their peak.
Apologies to Chivalry, Killing Floor 1, Halo Reach, Custom Robo and Etrian Odyssey Nexus. You aren't 5/5s. But you're close.

It's definitely recency bias because the game has been living rent free in my mind for a month, but E33.

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Only 13 games out of 700 i played.

Deus Ex

Ocarina of Time

Baldur's Gate 3

Bloodborne

Super Mario Galaxy

Resident Evil Remake

Metroid Prime

Warcraft 3

Symphony of the Night

Outer Wilds

Portal 2

Ultra Street Fighter 4

Doom

tranny zoomer

Psyvariar 2 and Border Down.

mario bros 3
mario 64
mario odyssey
breath of the wild
nightreign

Super Mario Galaxy

only good answer

Bruce Lee (atari/c64)
Super Mario Bros 3
Wonderboy 3
Doom Zelda 3
Resident Evil 4 (Gamecube original, none of the ports/remakes)

Super Metroid

The only reason i didn't pick that is because of the areas in maridia where you get stuck in the sand, and the fact that the space jump timing controls are broken/inconsistent.
Border Down has a 10/10 soundtrack i'll give you that. Yasuhisa Watanabe is GOAT

MGS3

Good Bait needs to be somewhat believable

Baldur's Gate 1 modded to contain the whole original saga.

No, it's probably not 10/10 but you asked which one is the first I think of and I always think of BG1 whenever whatever games are mentioned.

Apart from that:
Planescape Torment
Final Fantasy VII
Fallout 1, 2 and 3
Mass Effect 1,2 and 3
Dead Space 1,2 and, yes, 3
Metal Gear Solid 3
Devil May Cry 3
Resident Evil 4

Only good answer ITT

Can you anons tell me what's so great about Metroid Prime?

I tried so hard to get into it and I couldn't. It's slow, the shooting feels bad, it's slow, the atmosphere/vibe is great but Republic Commando also did the rain-on-the-visor thing in the early 2000s and it didn't involve hours of backtracking

Tasteless Faggot

It's an adventure game, not a shooter. If you're strictly a shooter guy and not a tendie, you're gonna get filtered.

Now compare it to Morrowind/Oblivion/Skyrim.

Funny how no one cares about writing, or voice acting, or plot holes in those games. It's just a fun fucking game, stop overthinking it

Jumping Flash was the reason to get a PS1

reddit told them it was good

Doom Eternal.

Funny how no one cares about writing, or voice acting, or plot holes in those games

No one cares about writing in an RPG

Do you really think ppl play Fallout 3 or any Bethesda game for their gameplay?

It's just a fun fucking game, stop overthinking it

It's just a worst version of FNV. Just admit you like slop

discombobulated story that you need to read a whole doom bible to make any sense of

the lore fucking sucks

No fight with Samuel Hayden wielding the crucible sword

8/10, and I'm being generous

>No fight with Samuel Hayden

TAG1

I'm talking about TES. TES games universally have terrible writing, quests, characters, story, etc. but nobody criticizes it or cares anywhere near the same degree as they do for Fallout 3. Same for JRPGs as well.

It's absolutely not the reason anyone is playing the games. It doesn't have to fit in your specific narrow expectation of an RPG.

It's just a worst version of FNV. Just admit you like slop

I have New Vegas on that same list rated higher than Fallout 3. Are you retarded?

DLC has too many Cyber Mancubus for my liking.

Kid Icarus Uprising
That's about it.

I like Fallout 3 because it lets you just be a comically evil asshole. Sometimes you just want to fuck around. Who cares if the world or quests aren't realistic, it's a fucking fantasy videogame. It's just fun to mess around and explore, blow people to bits, and be an asshole. The quests may not be well written and may be a bit corny at times, but they are at least memorable and enjoyable, far better than anything in TES games, and they have much more actual choice and player freedom than any of TES games. Oblivion had the best quests of the trilogy, but still pales in comparison to Fallout 3; funny how people can only compare New Vegas quest branching to 3 but will never compare New Vegas to the absolutely barebones fetch quests of TES.

EBF3.

funny how people can only compare New Vegas quest branching to 3 but will never compare New Vegas to the absolutely barebones fetch quests of TES

Could it be that TES never really had good branching quests while Fallout 1 and 2 were famous for their quests with multiple solutions? Especially 2, New Reno is a masterclass in quest making.

I can get behind all of these, but I vehemently disagree with these…

LBP

Dark Souls 3

The Evil Within

Morrowind
Oblivion
A Link To The Past
Demon Souls
Dark Souls
Bloodborne
Yakuza 0
Judgement
Mario 2
Mario 3
Pac-Man
Super Mario 3D Worlds (Switch version)

All three are absolute classics. Zero hesitation

It's over a decade later from totally different devs and publishers.

Did you get upset that Star Wars Battlefront wasn't like the Star Wars SNES games?

recently replayed through it, fucking love doom eternal. It's so good

Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (SEGA Master System)

It's still the same series. Do you think most people who complain about FO3 quest design are Bethesda fans?

star fox 64

outer wilds

OOT

I don't really care. I've never cared for "it's a good game, but a bad x game" arguments. You came into it with clearly wrong preconceived notions just based off name alone and then chose to be angry as a result. Not my problem.

but nobody criticizes it or cares anywhere near the same degree as they do for Fallout 3.

That's because Fallout 3's story, characters, and worlds are just that bad. It's not rocket science, buddy. There's a thing called suspension of disbelief, and Fallout 3 fails to maintain it completely. The game lacks any logical coherence; case in point, picrel, and no TES game has this level of bad writing and plot holes except for maybe Skyrim.

I have New Vegas on that same list rated higher

Liking one good game doesn't change the fact you like slop. You have shit taste it's okay to admit it, Zoomie

i actually legitimately think monster hunter world is a 10/10 game or as damn near perfect a game i've ever played, you have to really nitpick things to hate about it.

Sekiro
Black Souls 2

dkc3
lego star wars 3
sonic adventure
battlefront 2 (2005)
ffv
ultimate doom
Aoe2 DE

Suspension of disbelief only matters for immersion. I don't play Fallout 3 for immersion

le slop!!

le slop!!

reddit told me game bad so fuck you if you like it!!!

Yeah yeah whatever you say retard

Also that line is actually funny as fuck. Imagine getting taking a game so seriously that you actually get butthurt over it.

Dota
Yugioh tag force
MH3p
CB:RC
Metal max
Nascar rumble
Bomberman 64
CK2
ROTK 11
NA SOI
Fisherman's Bait 2

Ocarina of Time and Donkey Kong Country 2

Witcher 3, counter strike source

deus ex mgs3 tf2
basically all the games v hates for being flawless

I don't play Fallout 3 for immersion

Like I said you have shit taste you play it because you like slop, you love consuming garbage media.

reddit told me game bad so fuck you if you like it!!!

I don't use reddit. I have no idea what their consensus about it is, but I'm not surprised you do though, lol

Also that line is actually funny as fuck.

See this is the problem with your generation nothing is taken seriously, this is why we have shitty Television like the Amazon Fallout show it appeals to your low IQ and nigger ape sense of humor.

Chrono Trigger
Ocarina of Time
Earthbound

the last of us 2

Elder Ringo

Based OOT enjoyer. Still unmatched in terms of atmosphere, dungeon design, and that sense of mystery around every corner. Even after Majora's Mask dropped, Ocarina just hits different. Forest Temple theme still gives me chills every time.

unhinged seething and word salad of buzzwords over someone saying they enjoy a game

Fallout 3 raped your mom and killed your dog, I get it, I just don't care. Go cry to someone else.

to be fair it was a gruesome crime scene man you didn't see the carnage.

Chrono Trigger

can't think of a single game i've played that didn't have any flaws at all in them

Fallout 3 raped your mom and killed your dog, I get it, I just don't care. Go cry to someone else.

unhinged seething and word salad of buzzwords over someone saying you have shit taste and a low IQ.

All true btw.

Super Metroid. Least it is for me.

Resident Evil

BASED

TWEWY